Tonight on CBS FBI Most Wanted airs with an all-new Tuesday, May 13, 2025 season 6 episode 21, “Souls on ICE” and we have your FBI Most Wanted recap below.
In tonight’s FBI Most Wanted season 6 episode 21 as per the CBS synopsis, “After three men impersonating ICE officers raid a church in New Jersey, the Fugitive Task Force must earn the trust of the reverend to help find the men who were kidnapped.
Meanwhile, Remy confronts his own future after learning that Barnes is considering taking a new job”
Make sure to bookmark this spot and come back from 10 PM – 11 PM ET for our FBI recap. While you wait for our recap check out all our television news, spoilers, recaps & more, right here!
Tonight’s FBI Most Wanted Recap begins now – Refresh the Page often to get the most current updates!
In tonight’ FBI: Most Wanted episode, some men dressed as ICE Agents raided a church. They separated the men from the women. They detained three and the priest tried to fight back. She said they only had an administrative warrant. They needed a judicial warrant to arrest the men.
She knew that something was off about these agents. She tried to call the cops and that’s when the men attacked her. They knocked her unconscious by bodily throwing her into a pillar. The fake agents took off with their three prisoners. They checked their blood. They were looking for something in particular and threw a man out the moving van when he proved not to be it.
The priest pressed charges. The feds looked into it. They knew this wasn’t them. Homeland Security was denying this was them and so the FBI got involved.
Specifically, Remy with his team were brought in to bring the fake agents to justice. They also wanted to find the three missing men. These men were targeted because they came from a vulnerable group. The men barged in on a secret bilingual mass. It happened in the back room because these people were afraid of the real ICE showing up.
Somehow the fake agents knew about the backroom. They got the idea of faking the ICE gear because apparently it was well-known fact that it was easy to get. The team found out about it after they found another fake ICE Agent.
He tried to shake down a woman for money. He told her he’d deport her if she didn’t give him everything she had. The guy that did that was identified as Leonard Thompson. He was their shakedown artist, but not their kidnapper. The three men that were kidnapped were taken because they were young. And in pique condition.
The two they held onto were also known donor types. The men were taken for organ trafficking. They didn’t know until they were in cages that this wasn’t the real ICE. Plus, one of them had a green card.
He was here legally. He came over on a student visa. He was still in nursing school. He also lived with an American citizen. His boyfriend was willing to cooperate with the feds. Not many from the community were willing to do so. The priest talked. The immigration lawyer that the priest called talked. The others in the community were staying silent.
Reverend Sonya called them when one of the missing men showed up. He was badly injured. He showed up at the shelter and so Barnes realized that they shouldn’t spook him. She asked to go alone to talk to him. Hana acted as backup. She went undercover as a volunteer.
They stayed on comms. Remy allowed it because he knew that Barnes applied for a job in DC. It was closer to her kids. She’d work from the desk. He knew why she wanted the job. It’s why he recommended her for it once he found out about it. And he was willing to hear her out now because he wants to keep her.
Barnes hadn’t made up her mind on if she was going to take it when she went to the shelter. She found Miguel. She talked to him. Miguel admitted that the men tested his blood. He also mentioned that the leader wasn’t American. He had an accent. Yes, a white immigrant was targeting brown immigrants to traffic in organs.
His crew also had a Cuban among them. There were some Cubans that didn’t see themselves as immigrants. Or brown for that matter. They were given special privileges in the US once Castro took over. They got to come and instantly be granted rights.
They didn’t see that people wanted to deport them too. The Cuban in particular was named Angel. He and his friends pretended to be ICE agents when they showed up at the shelter. They didn’t count on the feds being there. Barnes and Hana opened fire on them. Hana shot Angel. The other two took off.
Not before they saw the leader’s tattoo. The guy they were looking for was Winston LaRay. He was a Neo-Nazi from South Africa. He came to America to spread his message of the dominant white race. He met his people through the gym he opened up in the city.
LaRay was getting his hands on the donor list. There were people that weren’t considered a priority and were rich enough to pay for a private transaction. They didn’t know this was illegal.
There was one woman willing to pay a million dollars for a liver that her mother needed. Her mother wouldn’t have survived staying on the donor list. She didn’t know she took part in organ harvesting. Or that innocent people were being forced to give up their organs. It’s actually been happening for a while and no one reported it because they thought those men were ICE.
It took the real federal agents firing at the fake ones for the community to trust the team. There was one man that came forward. The traffickers took his kidney. It wasn’t done properly.
It was actually infected. Barnes had him registered as a protected witness so that he could get medical treatment. Without the risk of deportation. The feds also went to the recruiting gym. They spotted LaRay. He ran when they identified themselves. Remy almost had him, but someone else came up behind him with a gun.
They planned on taking him hostage. He fought back. They were going to kill him right for being difficult when Barnes saved him. The men took off in their car because they thought it was too much trouble. They only went back to the gym to pick up propofol for the next surgery. It was an anesthetic.
The drug dealer got left behind. He happily worked with the feds just so he wouldn’t be charged with the other crimes. He told them about the surgeon they were using. The surgeon was Gary Hammett. He was an alcoholic that lost his job and license after it came out he was performing surgery drunk.
Hammett was broke. He also didn’t stop drinking. He needed the pay day. He never intended to kill anyone. They were supposed to remove the organs and release the men afterwards. Something changed this last time with the two men they grabbed at the church. The surgeon didn’t have help. He was drunk.
He butchered the surgery. He killed one of the men by accident. It was the first time he ever killed someone and so he was a little shaken. He tried to convince LaRay to leave while the getting was good. Only DeRay wanted that million dollars.
He was going to use the final victim to get the liver. Alonzo was an universal donor. He was about to be killed when the feds showed up. They stormed in. Alonzo escaped his captors in the confusion.
There was a fire fight. The men were picked off. Sometimes by each other. They went down and Alonzo was reunited with his boyfriend. They later thanked Barnes. She did more than they expected for a federal agent. It gave Barnes the boost she needed to run her own team. She later accepted the job in DC.
Remy was happy for her, but he was sad about losing her and Isobel was the best target of his anger.
THE END!